Skip to content

All content is available under the Open Government Licence v3.0, except where otherwise stated.

To view this licence, visit:
https://nationalarchives.gov.uk/doc/open-government-licence/version/3

or write to:
Information Policy Team,
The National Archives,
Kew,
London TW9 4DU

or email: psi@nationalarchives.gov.uk.

This publication is available at:
https://hmiprobation.justiceinspectorates.gov.uk.

Consultation on our thematic inspection and research programmes for 2027/2028

Consultation opened:
16/11/2026

1. Background (Back to top)

1.1. Under the Police and Criminal Justice Act 2006, we are required to consult key stakeholders on our inspection frameworks and programmes. It is our practice to consult more widely, with those we inspect and associated bodies who can provide valuable insight and information as we develop our framework and programmes.

1.2. This consultation sets out, in sections 2 and 3, proposals for our upcoming thematic inspection programme and research programme for 2027/2028. These are the proposals that we are consulting on.

1.3. We would very much welcome your comments on these proposals by 18 December 2026.


Thematic inspections

1.4. We apply a number of criteria to identify and prioritise our thematic topics, as follows:

  • Has this topic been identified as an ongoing area of weakness/concern in our core inspections?
  • Is this a ministerial priority?
  • Are there major change programmes or major national changes being applied to the operating model that require external oversight and assurance?

1.5. As part of our current thematic programme, we are undertaking scoping work for an inspection of recall to custody for adults. In addition, we have committed to the proposed joint criminal justice inspection programme for 2027–2029, which includes inspections of the experiences of victims of child sexual abuse, and the use of artificial intelligence and digital systems across the criminal justice system.


Research programme

1.6. We are committed to reviewing, developing, and promoting the evidence base for high-quality probation and youth justice services. We add value through our research programme by: (a) making valuable contributions to the policy and operational evidence base for probation and youth justice services; and (b) ensuring that our inspection frameworks, activities, and outputs are underpinned by evidence, helping to maximise their impact.

1.7. To help us prioritise topics for new research projects, we apply the following criteria.

Current level of risk
  • Significant changes to policy, service delivery or caseloads.
  • Risks to public protection/safeguarding.
  • Findings from inspections, research, and other forms of evidence.
Potential impact
  • Potential impact of our findings.
  • Ministerial and other key stakeholder interests.
  • Quality of current evidence.
  • Development of inspection standards.
Other
  • Suited to research or inspection.
  • Estimated resource requirements and timescales.

1.8. We are currently completing/undertaking research projects on the following topics, the last of which will continue into 2027/2028.

  • Delivering a high-quality, rights-compliant, and procedurally just service for all children and all victims.
  • Working together: designing and delivering collaborative approaches to support people on probation to build social capital.
  • Improving staff safety in probation and youth justice services.

1.9. In addition to our primary research projects, we have continued with secondary analysis of our inspection data and the publication of Academic Insights papers and reflections from research videos. See: Academic insights – HM Inspectorate of Probation and Reflections from research – HM Inspectorate of Probation.


Joint targeted area inspections

1.10. We will be maintaining our contribution to the joint targeted area inspection (JTAI) of child protection.

1.11. The JTAI programme is led by Ofsted. Inspectors assess how local authorities, the police, health, probation, and youth justice services are working together in an area to identify, support, and protect vulnerable children and young people.

1.12. The JTAI theme for September 2026 to May 2027 is the multi-agency response to younger children living with neglect. We are inspecting the work of the Probation Service.

1.13. JTAI reports can be viewed on the Ofsted website here: Joint inspections of local area services – GOV.UK.


2. Thematic inspection programme – suggested topics (Back to top)

2.1. We hope to carry out up to three thematic inspections during 2027/2028, including our commitment to the joint inspection programme.

2.2. We would like to get your views on which topics from the list below should be included in our thematic inspection programme for 2027/2028.


Adult

a) Recall: decisions and outcomes
An examination of why recalls are increasing, the decisions that lead to recall, and what recall achieves in protecting the public and supporting rehabilitation.

b) Work with adult sexual offenders
We last inspected this topic in 2018. Since then, there have been significant developments, including the increasing prominence of online offending, and changes to the management of people in the community. A thematic inspection would assess whether current probation practice supports effective rehabilitation while protecting victims, children, and the wider public.


Youth

c) Work with girls
The Inspectorate last examined work with girls as a thematic topic in 2014. Girls constitute a relatively small but distinct group within the youth justice system, with evidence highlighting high levels of adverse childhood experience, trauma, abuse, exploitation, and mental health need, alongside the importance of building trusting relationships and gender-responsive provision. A thematic inspection would assess whether youth justice services identify and respond effectively to girls’ specific needs, and work with partner agencies to improve safety and outcomes while avoiding the unnecessary entry of girls into the criminal justice system.

d) Neurodiversity and SEND
This is an area of increasing focus across youth justice, reflecting the significant overrepresentation of neurodivergent children and children with special educational needs and disability (SEND) in the system. Recent work has highlighted the importance of early identification, appropriate adaptations, improved staff understanding, and effective partnership working to meet these children’s needs. Building on the Academic Insights paper on a whole-child approach to neurodiversity, a thematic inspection would assess whether youth justice services identify and respond to children with neurodiversity and SEND effectively, make reasonable adjustments to support engagement and participation, and secure timely access to specialist assessment and support.


Consultation questions – thematic inspections. (Back to top)

We are seeking your views on which of the topics under 2.2. should be prioritised for our thematic inspection programme for 2027/2028. We are also open to receiving and considering additional suggestions on thematic topics from respondents. When proposing additional suggestions, please outline the following in support of your proposals:

  • What is the compelling evidence to suggest your proposal needs to be covered as a thematic inspection in this next financial year?
  • If you offer more than one proposal, what is the priority order and why?
  • Which project(s) described above would you replace with your proposal(s) and why?

Q1: Do you have any preferred thematic inspection topics from our list set out under 2.2 for 2027/2028?

Q2: Do you have any additional proposals for thematic inspection topics for 2027/2028?


3. Research programme – suggested topics (Back to top)

3.1. Taking into account our internal resource and external research budget for undertaking and commissioning projects, we will be looking to commission one new project during 2027/2028. Any further projects and activities will be undertaken internally.

3.2. We would like to get your views on which of the topics below should be prioritised for 2027/2028.

a) Developing a probation culture framework.
Probation service culture has become an increasingly important issue as the service seeks to navigate sustained operational pressures, workforce change, organisational restructuring, and potentially competing expectations about public protection, rehabilitation, performance, and professional judgement. Inspection findings consistently indicate that the quality of relationships, leadership, learning, staff confidence, and organisational behaviours are critical influences on practice quality. However, there is currently limited understanding of what constitutes a high-performing probation culture, how the culture varies between locations, and which cultural characteristics are most strongly associated with good outcomes for staff and people on probation. A research project could examine the relationship between organisational culture and service delivery, drawing on evidence from probation, youth justice, and wider public services. The focus would be on the development of a ‘probation culture framework’, capturing areas such as professionalism and professional autonomy, relationships and collaboration, leadership, psychological safety, inclusion, learning, innovation, and accountability.

b) Balancing rehabilitation and control: probation delivery following implementation of the Sentencing Act 2026. The implementation of the Sentencing Act and associated changes to probation practice create a timely opportunity to examine how probation practitioners balance the dual functions of supervision: protecting the public through appropriate restrictions and enforcement while supporting rehabilitation and positive change (termed ‘protective integration’; see Risk and Desistance: A Blended Approach to Risk Management). This tension has always been central to probation practice, but the recent legislative and operational reforms may affect how practitioners exercise professional judgement, engage with people under supervision, and manage risk. A research project could explore how staff interpret and implement the new arrangements, how people on probation experience supervision under the revised framework, and whether there are any unintended consequences for engagement, compliance, desistance, and public protection. It could give particular attention to identifying effective approaches to maintaining progress, preventing disengagement, and responding to changing circumstances once supervision intensity has reduced.

c) Youth justice responses to technology-facilitated offending and online harms. Children’s lives are increasingly shaped by digital environments, yet youth justice systems have often developed from more traditional understandings of offending, victimisation, and safeguarding. Online and technology-facilitated harms now encompass a wide range of behaviours, including cyber-enabled fraud, image-based abuse, online grooming, technology-facilitated sexual offending, harassment, exploitation, and harmful online communications. A research project could examine how youth justice services assess and respond to technology-facilitated offending, the skills and confidence of practitioners, partnership arrangements with schools and safeguarding agencies, and the suitability of existing interventions. It could also explore children’s motivations, vulnerabilities, and developmental needs within digital contexts, recognising that online behaviour often differs from conventional offending patterns. It could give particular attention to the complex ways in which children may be victims of harm, responsible for causing harm, or both, including at the same time. Understanding these overlapping experiences will be critical to ensuring that responses balance safeguarding, accountability, and opportunities for positive change appropriately.

d) Young adults’ experiences of youth justice and probation supervision.
Over the past decade, youth justice and probation have evolved in different directions; youth justice has increasingly embraced child-centred, trauma-informed, strengths-based, and developmental approaches, while probation has operated within a different legislative, organisational, and operational context. Inspection findings have revealed notable differences in performance between the two services, with youth justice generally achieving stronger results across a range of areas. This research project would explore how young adults experience supervision across the systems, focusing on those who have had recent experience of both. It could examine differences in relationships with practitioners, levels of support and challenge, approaches to risk management, responsiveness to maturity and individual needs, and opportunities for participation and engagement. It could give particular attention to identifying which aspects of practice young adults find most helpful, the forms of support lost, gained or altered as they move between services, and how services can better respond to the developmental needs of young adulthood. The research would also contribute to wider debates about young adulthood, maturity, and age-appropriate practice, helping to identify how services can better respond to the needs of young adults.

3.3. Alongside our primary research projects, we will continue to publish Academic Insights papers, update our evidence webpages, and undertake secondary analysis of our inspection data. Our current secondary analysis projects look at:

  • youth justice inspection ratings/scores by local area characteristics
  • key components and drivers of high-quality work with children
  • the quality of delivery in youth out-of-court resolution cases
  • children subject to wider local authority involvement
  • the views of people on probation: relationships, engagement, and support.

Consultation questions – research programme (Back to top)

We are seeking your views on which of the project areas set out in section 3.2 should be prioritised for 2027/2028. We are also open to receiving and considering additional project areas from respondents. If you propose alternative suggestions, please outline the following in support of them:

  • What is the compelling evidence to suggest your proposal needs to be covered by HM Inspectorate of Probation as a research project in this next financial year?
  • If you offer more than one proposal, what is the priority order and why?
  • Which project(s) described above would you replace with your proposal(s) and why?

Q3: Do you have any preferred research topics from our list set out in 3.2 for 2027/2028?

Q4: Do you have any alternative proposals on research topics for 2027/ 2028?


4. Conclusion (Back to top)

4.1. In this consultation we have set out suggestions for thematic inspection topics and research projects for 2027/2028. Ministers may ask us to conduct specific pieces of work or investigations over the course of 2027/2028, and we will respond to these and any risks as they arise.

4.2. We would very much appreciate your views on our thematics and research programmes for 2027/2028 by Friday 18 December 2026.

4.3. Please direct your responses and any queries to: communications@hmiprobation.gov.uk